Recent Baofeng vs. Classic Yaesu

My first real ham radios were a pair of outdated Yaesu handhelds -- The VX-7R, and the VX-2. Both of them entered production more than a decade ago, and while I believe Yaesu still makes the VX-7R, the VX-8 series de-throned it as Yaesu's Flagship Handheld radio in 2008. The VX-2 was replaced by the VX-3 in 2007.

When I got my license a few years ago, inexpensive handheld radios were just starting to become popular. I've had more than a year to put two polar-opposites head-to-head against each other.

I won't dwell much on my VX-2 or the newer VX-3. These diminutive Yaesu handhelds pack a lot of features into a small package, but with a maximum of 1.5 watts when running on battery power, they aren't very practical for most hams. It's a good, compact radio if you only want to monitor or scan ham and business band channels.  Much of what I write below will hold true for the VX-2 and VX-3 compared to the similarly-sized, low-power Baofeng UV-3R radios.

To provide some context, I've been using the Baofeng almost daily since early March of 2013. The stock battery in my Yaesu had become almost unusable, and the cheap ($20) replacement battery failed within 9 months. A new "official" Yaesu battery for the VX-7R costs between 70 and 100 dollars depending where you look. I opted to spend half of that on a new, cheap Baofeng UV-5R. After more than a year of using it, I figure I'm qualified to make a comparison.

On with the show.

Left: Baofeng UV-5RA (Circa 2012)
Right: Yaesu VX-7R (Circa 2007)

Let's start with the Baofeng, because this radio, and ones like it available under brand names such as Wouxun and TYT, have become quite popular among new ham radio operators mostly due to their low prices, ranging anywhere from $30 to $160. Many of these radios were designed to be programmed for Business Band (FCC Part 90) use, and some even bear type certification for this use. They are clearly competing with Motorola and Kenwood in the business radio arena. Others, like my UV-5RA, bear no type certification and can only be legally used for ham radio frequencies.

The Good:
  • These radios will get you on the air for 2m and 70cm repeaters, which is many peoples' first step to becoming an active ham radio operator.
  • On simplex freqencies, they make excellent walkie-talkies (assuming everyone's licensed, of course) and will provide much better range than a pair of FRS or hand-held CB radios. Highly recommended for camping, bike trips, road convoys, the bug-out-bag, etc.
  • This radio can receive broadcast FM, and can receive and transmit in the 136-174 MHz and 400-480MHz bands including weather radio.
  • Relatively inexpensive
  • Long battery life, even for long-winded ragchews or an active day helping with a public service event (marathons, bike races, storm spotting)
  • The backlight is very bright and the display is fairly easy to read in all lighting conditions.
The Bad:
  • Although it displays two frequencies at once, it cannot actually use both at the same time. "Dual Watch" tries to emulate simultaneous use of both tuners.
  • Dual Watch functionality can be problematic and lead to you inadvertently transmitting on the "wrong" tuner if you're not careful. 
  • Scanning is very slow: in 5kHz steps, it takes exactly one minute to scan 1MHz. 
  • Poor interference rejection either due to or causing RF squelch to be over-sensitive
  • When using CTCSS tone for squelch, the speaker still un-mutes when no CTCSS carrier is present on occasion
The Ugly:
  • The backlight is very bright and cannot be turned down, only off. You can change the color between a reddish-orange, purple and blue. At night, the display seems far too bright to me.
  • The construction is cheap.
  • Ambiguous menu abbreviations are difficult to navigate without a manual.
  • Complaints of parts failures are common.
In short, this makes a good back-up radio, or one to lend to a new ham for a few weeks while they save up for a rig, but it leaves plenty to be desired. I'm not sure I'd recommend that a new ham goes out and buys one as their only radio.

The Yaesu, by comparison, has quite a bit more going for it, at the expense of... well... money.

The Good:
  • VERY fast scanning: 1MHz at 5hKz increments in 10 seconds. 
  • Dual VFO functionality can receive from two channels at the same time. 
  • Can receive almost every frequency between 500kHz and 1GHz, with a few gaps in coverage for legacy mobile phone frequencies that the FCC forbids reception of. This includes weather radio, AM/FM broadcast radio, CB, shortwave and most analog two-way radio transmissions.
  • Quad-band transmitter that's capable of operating at full power on 2m and 70cm as well as limited power on 1.25m (220 MHz) and 6m (50MHz). 
  • Alloy case is an excellent heatsink and construction is very solid
  • Water-resistant to 10 feet, which makes it my go-to radio for storm spotting if I need to be outside my home or my car.
  • "Smart scan" loads in-use ham frequencies into memory for you automatically (requires a few hours of scanning)
  • "Frequency counter" mode, which isn't really a frequency counter, but is good for finding the frequency being used by almost any nearby RF transmitter
  • "Spectrum analyzer" mode that I've found comes in handy for rough calibration of transmitters, identifying spurious emissions and visualizing how wideband certain transmissions are (hint: my 900 MHz wireless headphones use almost 100KHz of bandwidth!) 
  • Severe weather alert mode
  • Superior interference rejection
  • Can be hacked in interesting ways with software. Don't get yourself into trouble.
  • Menu options are pretty self-explanatory.
The Bad:
  • Cost! The radio, brand new, retails for $350 or more, making it literally 7 times more expensive than the average Baofeng on Amazon. Used, expect to pay $250 for one in good condition.
  • Most official parts and accessories from Yaesu are also expensive, especially batteries.
  • Overwhelming number of menu options might daunt some users.
 The Ugly:
  • The alloy case is prone to superficial cracks and blemishes.
  • The display has very flexible options for large numbers, but seems difficult to read with default settings. 
  • The backlight is adjustable, but its highest setting isn't very bright.

Programming either of these radios is a task best left to the software, which may cost money, and requires a programming cable, which definitely costs money. Programming either of them from the keypad can be a chore, but that's how I opted to set mine up. Overall, the Yaesu's menus make programming channels in with meaningful labels a lot easier than the Baofeng.

There are quite a few websites dedicated to hacking and using the cheaper radios. The one I stumbled across most often was http://www.miklor.com. Without the programming guide there, I would have never figured out how to get the local repeaters plugged into my Baofeng.

This week, the Baofeng experiment ended, as I finally caved in and bought a new battery for the VX-7R. The moral of the story is that you really do get what you pay for a lot of the time, and the more expensive handheld radios can pay off in the long run. The Baofeng will still be my backup radio. It's proven to be reliable, and when you just need to get on the air, that's what counts.

blog comments powered by Disqus